REPORT TO: Commissioner
Hearing
MEETING DATE: Monday 26 November
2018
FROM: COMMITTEE SECRETARY
Christine
Hilton
SUBJECT: A
Resource Consent to establish a site for the processing of extracted river
gravels (Defined as ‘Mining’ in the proposed Hastings District
Plan) and to erect associated ancillary structures (RMA20180258) Russell Roads
Limited
1.0 INTRODUCTION
1.1 This is a covering report relating
to an application for resource consent to establish a site for the processing
of extracted river gravels (Defined as ‘Mining’ in the Proposed Hastings District
Plan) and to erect associated ancillary structures (RMA20180258) Russell Roads
Limited.
1.2 This agenda can be viewed on the
Council website and a reference hardcopy is held at the Ground Floor Reception,
Council’s Civic Administration Building, Lyndon Road East, Hastings and
at each of the district libraries (in Havelock North, Flaxmere and Hastings).
1.3 For ease of reference the
recommendation from the attached Planner’s Report is also set out below,
as part of this covering report.
2.0 RECOMMENDATIONS
A. That pursuant to Rule
EM8 of the Proposed Hastings District Plan (As Amended by Decisions 15
September 2015) and Sections 104, 104B and 108 of the Resource Management Act
1991, resource consent as a Discretionary Activity is GRANTED to Russell
Roads Limited to undertake the processing of gravel associated with gravel
extraction activities (defined as ‘Mining’) on a site legally
described as Lot 4 Deposited Plan 463659, CFR 614100 and physically located
along the bank of the Ngaruroro River, near Maraekakaho.
B. That pursuant to Rule
NH12 and Sections 104, 104B, 104D and 108 of the Resource Management Act 1991
resource consent as a Non-Complying Activity is GRANTED to Russell Roads Limited to erect permanent buildings within the River Hazard
Overlay on a site legally described as Lot 4 Deposited
Plan 463659, CFR 614100 and physically located along the bank of the Ngaruroro
River, near Maraekakaho.
C. That pursuant to Section
348 of the Local Government Act 1974 the Hastings District Council approves the
granting of a right of way over Part Lot 1 Deposited Plan 357840 and Lot 3
Deposited Plan 473957 (CFR 663412) in favour of the Hawke’s Bay Regional
Council, on the alignment shown in the application (attached below as
‘Proposed Site and Access Route’) with a minimum width of 6 metres.
SUBJECT TO THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS:
GENERAL
1. That unless otherwise
altered by the consent conditions, the proposal shall proceed in accordance
with the plans and information submitted in the application Resource Consent: RMA20120258,
application received 25 June 2018, specifically:
a) Application (HDC Ref: 103419#0004 - #0008)
b) Further information provided (103419#0016,
#0017, #0020, #0103)
2. That no more than three full time
equivalent staff (excluding truck drivers) shall be onsite at any one time.
3. That no retail sales of gravel shall
occur from the site.
4. The activity shall be carried out between
the hours of 0700 to 1800 hours Monday to Friday and 0700 to 1530 hours on
Saturday’s. No operations shall take place on Sunday’s or public
holidays.
5. All processed aggregate stockpiles shall
not exceed 6 metres in height and all aggregate awaiting processing shall not
exceed 10 metres in height.
6. That no more than 1020 cubic metres of
aggregate shall be processed per day.
CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT PLAN
7. Prior to the
commencement of any activities allowed by this consent, the consent holder
shall submit a Construction Management Plan (CMP) prepared by a suitably
qualified and experienced person(s) that details the way in which construction
works for the proposed access and any landscaping bund will be managed to
ensure there will be no adverse effects beyond the site to the satisfaction of
the Environmental Consents Manager, Hastings District Council (or nominee). The
CMP shall, as a minimum, address the following:
a) Timing and staging of construction works;
b) Reporting and auditing;
c) Complaints handling and reporting
procedure;
d) All measures that will be undertaken to
mitigate potential construction noise effects to ensure compliance with the
conditions of this consent;
e) Any other measures that will be
undertaken to mitigate potential nuisance effects;
f) The contact details for the site
manager;
g) Compliance with the provisions of the New
Zealand Standard NZS 6803:1999 “Acoustics – Construction
Noise.”
CONSTRUCTION NOISE
8. All construction work,
being the development of the access road and the construction of any permanent
noise control or landscaping bunds on the site, shall be designed and conducted
to ensure that noise measured at the notional boundary of any dwelling or noise
sensitive activity does not exceed the Typical Duration Limits Specified in
NZS6803:1999.
9. All construction noise
shall be measured in accordance with New Zealand Standard 6803:1999
“Acoustics – Construction Noise.”
10. All construction work shall be
limited to the hours of 7:00am – 5:00pm Monday to Friday and 8:00am
– 5:00pm Saturday (with no work on Sundays or public holidays).
SITE MANAGEMENT PLAN
11. A Site Management Plan (SMP) shall
be prepared by suitably qualified professional/s, and shall be submitted to the
satisfaction of the Council’s Environmental Consents Manager, (or
nominee), Hastings District Council, prior to the commencement of any activities
allowed by this consent. This plan shall be updated annually and provided to
the Council on the each anniversary of this consent and shall detail how all
the conditions of this consent shall be complied with, and shall also include
(but is not restricted to) the following:
(i) All details of site layout, the location
of aggregate and stockpiles, areas of hardstand, ancillary buildings, site
access, and the internal and external transport routes.
(ii) Details of how conditions of this consent in
respect of Hazardous Substances, Dust, Noise and Traffic Movements will be
complied with.
(iii) The total volume of aggregate processed per
annum for the previous year.
(iv) The annual update shall address how any complaints
received in the previous year have been addressed.
OVERSPILL, DUST AND DEBRIS
12. That the consent holder shall
submit a final Dust Management Plan to the satisfaction of Council's
Environmental Consents Manager, Planning and Regulatory Services (or nominee)
that sets out the measures necessary to ensure the prevention of dust nuisance
on adjacent land owners or occupiers, and along the access route, prior to the
commencement of any activities allowed by this consent. Measures shall include,
but are not limited to, the following:
a) During
dry windy periods the aggregate shall be moistened prior to processing and for
transporting beyond the site.
b) The
access roadway shall be kept free of overspill, dust and debris.
c) All
aggregates transported from the site shall be covered or carried in a dampened
state to prevent dust annoyance. In the event of mud or gravel being carried
off the property and deposited on the public carriageway the consent holder
will arrange for its removal as soon as is reasonably possible.
d) Should
offensive or objectionable dust be observed beyond the processing site boundary
the activities generating the dust must cease immediately and must not restart
until such time as the dust nuisance has been remedied.
NOISE
13. The following noise limits shall not be exceeded at
any point within the notional boundary of any noise sensitive activity:
|
Control
Hours
|
Noise
Level
|
|
0700
to 1900 hours
|
50
dB LAeq (15 min)
|
|
1900
to 2200 hours
|
45
dB LAeq (15 min)
|
|
2200
to 0700 hours the following day
|
40
dB LAeq (15 min)
|
|
2200
to 0700 hours the following day
|
75
dB LAFmax
|
14. Noise shall be measured in accordance with the
requirements of NZS 6801:2008: Acoustics - Measurement of Environmental Sound
and assessed in accordance with the requirements of NZS 6802:2008: Acoustics -
Environmental Noise.
15. Tonal reverse alarms are prohibited on
all vehicles that are permanently located on the site, including the loader,
excavator and any other mobile plant.
16. No plant or machinery shall be
operated on site that has a special audible characteristic as defined by
NZS6802:2008 Acoustics - Environmental Noise.
17. Where stockpiling exists and where
it can practicably be used to screen machinery, the consent holder shall take
all practicable steps to utilise stock piles to reduce noise levels to
neighbouring properties.
18. Within three months of the date
this consent is granted the Consent Holder shall demonstrate to the
Environmental Consents Manager, Hastings District Council via field measurement
and assessment that the noise limits set out in Condition 13 are complied with
at all times. Sound levels shall be measured and assessment completed by a
suitably experienced acoustic expert acceptable to the Council.
Measurement shall be in accordance with New Zealand Standard 6801:2008
Acoustics - Measurement of Environmental Sound, and assessment in accordance
with New Zealand Standard 6802:2008 Acoustics - Environmental Noise. The
requested Noise Monitoring Compliance Report shall be submitted to the
Environmental Consents Manager, Hastings District Council within 2 weeks of
completing the field measurements.
19. In the event of non-compliance with
Condition 13 the applicant shall implement any appropriate noise control work
within one week and measure the noise once this treatment is in place within 2
weeks. A copy of these measurements shall be provided to the Environmental
Consents Manager (or nominee), Hastings District Council, within one week of
the monitoring being undertaken.
LANDSCAPING &
SCREENING
20. That the consent holder shall
submit a landscape plan prepared by a suitably qualified and experienced person
for the approval of the Environmental Consents Manager (or nominee), prior to the commencement of any activities allowed by this consent. The landscaping plan shall include planting
specifications detailing the specific planting species, the number of plants
provided, locations, heights/Pb sizes. Specifically, the landscaping plan shall
provide for:
a) Compliance
with the recommendations of the Landscape and Visual
Impact Assessment undertaken by Sue Dick of Eastern Earth Landscape Architects, dated 5 June 2018, submitted with the
application.
b) Use of the following tree species: Willow/Salix matsudana, or other non-invasive Salix spp, or
Poplar/Populus nigra x euramericana 'Crows Nest'; or Tasmanian blackwood/Acacia
melanoxylon.
c) The trees
shall have a minimum height of 1.5 metres when planted and be maintained at a
minimum height of 5 metres;
d) Methods used to ensure the successful establishment of the trees;
e) Provision
for irrigation.
21. Prior to
the commencement of any activities allowed by this consent the landscaping shall be planted and irrigation
installed in accordance with the approved landscape plan required by Condition
20.
22. That in regard to Conditions 20
and 21 the required landscaping and screening shall be maintained for the
duration of this consent to the satisfaction of the Environmental Consents
Manager (or nominee), Hastings District Council.
Advice
Note: “Maintained” means the
ongoing replacement of any dangerous, dead or dying matter, the replacement of
any plants that are lost or are otherwise defective and the general
preservation of the landscaping to a healthy standard.
23. Prior to the commencement of any activities allowed by this consent the
processing site shall be fenced off to prevent public access in order to create
a secure area.
SITE ACCESS
24. A copy of the proposed easement across Pt Lot 1 DP 357840 and Lot 3 DP 473957 (CFR 663412) in
favour of the Hawke’s Bay Regional Council shall be provided to
the Environmental Consents Manager (or nominee), Hastings District Council,
prior to the commencement of any activities allowed by this consent.
25. Engineering plans detailing the construction of the
State Highway 50 entrances and internal access in accordance with the
requirements of the New Zealand Transport Agency and the Hastings District
Council Engineering Code of Practice 2011 and Proposed Hastings District Plan,
shall be submitted to the Environmental Consents Manager (or nominee), Hastings
District Council, prior to construction.
26. The
access route from State Highway 50 to the processing site shall have a chip
seal road surface, or similar, be constructed in accordance with the HDC approved
design, and be maintained to ensure an uneven road surface does not develop.
All internal roads shall be maintained to a high standard so that pot holes and
an uneven road surface do not cause unnecessary body and tray rattle on
vehicles.
27. Construction of the State Highway 50 vehicle
crossing, right turning lane and internal access shall be completed in
accordance with the approved design(s) and to the satisfaction of the
Environmental Consents Manager (or nominee), Hastings District Council, prior
to the commencement of any activities allowed by this consent.
28. The consent holder shall submit a Statement of
Professional Opinion from a suitably qualified and registered professional
engineer that the construction works for the access and internal roads have
been completed in accordance with the approved plans, prior to the commencement
of any activities allowed by this consent.
29. All vehicle entranceway construction work shall be
undertaken by a contractor who has been pre-approved by the New Zealand
Transport Agency to work in the boundaries of the legal road.
TRAFFIC AND
TRANSPORT
30. That a Traffic
Management Plan prepared by a suitably
qualified professional be submitted, for the approval of the Environmental
Consents Manager, Hastings District Council prior
to the commencement of the activity and shall include, but is not limited to, the following:
a) Specific details
relating to vehicle
movements, and community safety;
b) The number and timing of truck movements throughout the day;
c) A requirement that all vehicles shall be securely
covered or loads carried in a dampened
state to prevent
loss of load;
d) A requirement that all vehicles shall have their headlights turned on
throughout operation to provide increased awareness and improved visibility;
e) A direction
to drivers that every truck driver will be briefed
on the approved Traffic
Management Plan, and driver protocol, and details of how this will be achieved;
f) A
requirement that a speed limit of 20km/hr shall be implemented on site.
31. The Consent Holder shall ensure all on
site activities authorised by this consent are carried out in accordance with
the approved Traffic Management Plan for this site.
32. That the number of heavy vehicle
movements shall not exceed a peak daily rate of 85 or a peak hourly rate of 18
per hour. (Note: a vehicle movement includes the arrival or departure of
the vehicle).
33. That once
the access route from State Highway 50 to the processing site is operational all vehicle traffic shall use this access.
No access to the site from the unformed legal road off Kereru Road shall be
allowed.
HAZARDOUS SUBSTANCES
34. The consent holder shall ensure all plant and
equipment is stored on a hardstand area, bunded to prevent contamination by
accidental spillage or leakage of fuels, oils or other contaminants.
35. The consent holder shall provide anti-contaminant
traps to trap any spillage or leakage of contaminants, the content of which
shall be removed from site for disposal as necessary.
36. Any hazardous substance stored on-site shall be
stored in a locked and secured storage facility bunded to prevent contamination
by spillage or leakage of fuels, oils or other contaminants.
END OF OPERATIONS
37. Within
6 months of the activities authorised by this consent ceasing or the expiry of
this consent the consent holder shall ensure any noise control screening is
removed and all parts of the processing site are rehabilitated to the
satisfaction of the Environmental
Consents Manager (or nominee), Hastings
District Council.
REVIEW CONDITION
38. Pursuant to Section 128 of the Resource Management
Act 1991 the Council may review any condition(s) of this consent at any time or
upon receipt of a justified complaint, to ensure the effectiveness of
conditions imposed in addressing adverse effects on the environment that might
otherwise arise from the exercise of this consent.
MONITORING
39. That a monitoring deposit of
$220 (including GST) shall be payable to cover the reasonable costs of
monitoring compliance with the above conditions in accordance with Council's
schedule of charges. In the event of non-compliance being detected by monitoring
or justified complaint and/or the costs of monitoring consent exceeding the
deposit, the costs to Council of any additional monitoring shall be paid by the
consent holder in accordance with the Council's advertised schedule of fees.
40. That all costs associated with complying with any or all conditions of this consent shall be
borne by the consent holder.
WITH THE REASONS FOR THIS RECOMMENDATION BEING:
1. The
GENERAL conditions ensure that the development proceeds in accordance
with the plans and information submitted and assessed.
2. The CONSTRUCTION
MANAGEMENT PLAN condition ensures that appropriate construction methods are
undertaken during the construction of the proposal.
3. The
CONSTRUCTION NOISE conditions ensure that the proposal complies with the
New Zealand Standard for Construction Noise (NZS6803:1999).
4. The
SITE MANAGEMENT PLAN condition ensures that the activities onsite are in
accordance with best practice and the conditions of this consent.
5. The
OVERSPILL, DUST AND DEBRIS conditions ensure that any adverse effects
resulting from the operation of the proposal do not adversely affect adjacent
properties.
6. The NOISE
conditions ensure that all noise generated by the proposal is appropriately
designed to ensure that the noise limits for the Plains Zone are complied with.
7. The
LANDSCAPING & SCREENING conditions ensure that the proposal will be
adequately landscaped and screened from adjacent properties and road users so
that the amenity of the area is maintained.
8. The
SITE ACCESS and TRAFFIC AND TRANSPORT conditions ensure that safe and efficient access
to the districts roading network is provided.
9. The
HAZADOUS SUBSTANCES conditions ensure that any hazardous substances are
appropriately located to avoid adverse effects on the environment.
10. The
END OF OPERATION condition ensures that the site is rehabilitated when
the activity ceases.
11. The REVIEW
CONDITION ensures the conditions of consent can be reviewed to ensure any
adverse effects since the granting of consent can be addressed.
12. The
MONITORING conditions ensure that the consent holder pays the actual and
reasonable charges associated with monitoring the consent and that all
conditions of consent are monitored for compliance.
13. The ADVERSE EFFECTS of this proposal are less
than minor, in that:
Visual
Amenity
· Landscaping will occur in front of the site
thereby helping to screen and maintain the amenity of the area. Any adverse
visual effects are likely to be less than minor as confirmed by an expert
landscape architect;
· That
while the character of the site will be affected from that which presently
exists, visual effects can be mitigated by the imposition of appropriate
conditions;
· That due to the
contrast between the processing site and surrounding vegetated areas, the
processing site will be noticeable in the landscape when seen from the houses
on the hill to the south. Due to the vastness of the views of the river plains
and the relatively small scale of the processing site and with the proposed
screen planting, it is considered that the site will have a less than minor
adverse effects on these views when seen from these locations;
· It is acknowledged that the proposed screen planting won't totally
screen the site from the viewing locations on the upper parts of the hill due
to the viewing angle. However, the planting will reduce the visual dominance in
the landscape;
· The machinery will not be prominent in the landscape amongst the
gravel and given the height of the stockpiles at up to 10 metres much of the
machinery will be well screened from the adjacent dwellings on the hillside
opposite the site.
Noise
· Noise from the proposal as assessed by suitably
qualified acoustic experts has been shown to comply with the Proposed District
Plan noise limits at the notional boundary of all noise sensitive activities;
· Acoustic advice confirms that noise
effects resulting from the increase in heavy traffic movements on SH 50 is
negligible;
· All
activities occurring on the site are confined to normal daytime hours and there
will not be any effects on sleep disturbance given that all operations will be
finished by 6pm weekdays and 3:30pm on Saturday;
· Hours of operation of the activity have been limited to 7am to 6pm
Monday to Friday and 7:00am to 3:30pm Saturday;
· The
acoustic peer review of the applicant’s noise assessment by Hegley
Acoustics has confirmed that the proposal can comply with the Proposed District
Plans noise limits at the notional boundary of all noise sensitive activities
in the vicinity and reduced noise limits have been recommended given the nature
of the activity.
Traffic
· In relation to traffic movements there is no restriction on the
number of traffic movements for rural sites throughout the District. Given the
site is accessed from a State Highway the Hastings District Council is not the
road controlling authority in this instance as the State Highway is the responsibility
of the NZTA. As the NZTA have provided their written approval to the proposal
subject to upgrading the intersection to their satisfaction, no adverse effects
on the road network are anticipated;
· While it is acknowledged that there is the potential for conflict
given the number of heavy traffic movements proposed which will be
approximately 18 per hour on the busiest day between 7am and 6pm, the
organisation responsible for the State Highway and access to and from it (being
the New Zealand Transport Agency) has provided their written approval to the
proposal, subject to the upgrading of the vehicle crossing and the addition of
a right turn lane, meaning that any adverse effects on the State Highway must
be disregarded;
· Safe and efficient access can be provided
subject to the upgrading of the vehicle access to NZTA requirements;
· Sufficient onsite parking and loading can be
provided;
· The access road from SH50 to the proposed
processing site will be sealed and will be required to be maintained to a high
standard to reduce potential noise from heavy vehicle movements.
Dust
· Appropriate conditions in relation to dust and
the adoption of a dust management plan will ensure that any off site effects
from dust can be mitigated.
Natural
Hazards
· Based on advice from the Hawke’s Bay Regional Council it can
be concluded that there are no adverse effects of the proposal in relation to
natural hazards, and in relation to flooding, the proposed activity poses
little risk.
Reverse
Sensitivity
· Gravel extraction and processing is not a particularly
‘sensitive’ land use, and is unlikely to restrict the ability of
adjoining land owners to carry out legitimate/lawful activities.
River
Access
· The proposal is located entirely within a site owned by the
Hawke’s Bay Regional Council and no change to the existing river access
will result from the proposal.
14. The
proposal is consistent with the OBJECTIVES, POLICIES and OTHER
PROVISIONS of the Proposed Hastings District Plan, in that:
· The adverse effects on the environment can be mitigated by
appropriate conditions and will be no more than minor;
· The proposal will support activities that utilise the
Heretaunga Plains resource in a sustainable manner, while having a minor effect
on the life-supporting capacity on the soil resource;
· The scale and
intensity of the activity does not restrict the sustainable management of the
wider Rural Zone soil resource;
· Safe and efficient access to and from the site can be
provided;
· The proposal will not increase the risk of natural hazards;
· The amenity of Rural Zone can be maintained.
15. In terms of Section 104(1)(c) the
proposal is not contrary to the overall policy directions for the Rural Zone or
the District Wide Earthworks and Mining Section and it is unlikely to pose a
‘significant challenge’ to the key Objectives and Policies of the
Proposed District Plan.
16. In terms of Section 104D in
relation to Natural Hazards the effects on the environment will be no more than
minor and the proposal is not contrary to the key objectives and policies of
the Proposed Hastings District Plan. The proposal can therefore qualify for
consideration under Section 104D, and pursuant to Section 104(1), and subject
to Part II of the Act.
17. Overall the proposal promotes
sustainable management as required by Part II of the Resource Management Act
1991 in that:
· It
will result in acceptable adverse effects on landscape, rural character and
amenity effects;
· Any potential adverse effects can be avoided,
remedied or mitigated by conditions of consent.
1. To
avoid doubt, except as otherwise allowed by this resource consent, all landuses
must comply with all remaining standards and terms of the relevant Hastings
District Plan. The proposal must also comply with the Building Act 2004,
Engineering Code of Practice and Hawke’s Bay Regional Plans. All
necessary consents and permits shall be obtained prior to development.
2. Under Section 125 of the Resource Management Act 1991 a resource
consent will lapse if not given effect to within 5 years of the date the
consent was granted, unless an extension is granted under Section 125(1A).
Attachments:
|
1
|
Final Hearing Report
|
103419#0105
|
|
|
2
|
Application for Mining activity involving the
processing of gravel, erection of two accessory buildings and the
construction of a new vehicle access
|
103419#0004
|
|
|
3
|
Certificate of Title
|
103419#0005
|
|
|
4
|
Development Plans
|
103419#0116
|
|
|
5
|
Description of Proposal and Assessment of
Environmental Effects
|
103419#0007
|
|
|
6
|
Supporting Documents Traffic, Noise and Landscape
Reports
|
103419#0119
|
Document 2
|
|
7
|
S92 Further Information Required Letter
|
103419#0107
|
Document 2
|
|
8
|
Further Info provided Re Lease Agreement and Speed
Restrictions (1 of 2)
|
103419#0016
|
Document 2
|
|
9
|
Further Info provided (2 of 2)
|
103419#0017
|
Document 2
|
|
10
|
NZTA Written Approval
|
103419#0018
|
Document 2
|
|
11
|
s92 request
|
103419#0108
|
Document 2
|
|
12
|
Hegley Acoustic Peer Review
|
103419#0049
|
Document 2
|
|
13
|
Request for Further information following
submissions
|
103419#0109
|
Document 2
|
|
14
|
Russell Roads HBRC Consent 2018/2019
|
103419#0051
|
Document 2
|
|
15
|
Further Information After submissions PDF (Dust
Management Plan, Silica Dust, Access Roads)
|
103419#0106
|
Document 2
|
|
16
|
Submission #1 David & Ngaire Bryant
|
103419#0026
|
Document 3
|
|
17
|
Submission #2 Joanne Hammond
|
103419#0056
|
Document 3
|
|
18
|
Submission #3 Shaun Kavanagh
|
103419#0057
|
Document 3
|
|
19
|
Submission #4 John Sorensen
|
103419#0058
|
Document 3
|
|
20
|
Submission #5 Brian Guerin
|
103419#0059
|
Document 3
|
|
21
|
Submission # 6 Joe Simmons
|
103419#0118
|
Document 3
|
|
22
|
Submission #7 Cunie Leijen
|
103419#0061
|
Document 3
|
|
23
|
Submission #8 Darryl Judd
|
103419#0062
|
Document 3
|
|
24
|
Submission #9 Jennifer Coles
|
103419#0063
|
Document 3
|
|
25
|
Submission # 10 Jennifer Foote
|
103419#0064
|
Document 3
|
|
26
|
Submission #11 HBRC
|
103419#0065
|
Document 3
|
|
27
|
Submission #12 Maria Ferguson
|
103419#0067
|
Document 3
|
|
28
|
Submission #13 Patricia Reddy
|
103419#0068
|
Document 3
|
|
29
|
Submission #14 David Bloomfield
|
103419#0070
|
Document 3
|
|
30
|
Submission #15 Jennie Bloomfield
|
103419#0071
|
Document 3
|
|
31
|
Submission #16 Jonathon Brough
|
103419#0072
|
Document 3
|
|
32
|
Submission #17 Kathleen Hughes
|
103419#0073
|
Document 3
|
|
33
|
Submission #18 Kara Duncan Hewitt
|
103419#0074
|
Document 3
|
|
34
|
Submission #19 Michelle Monteith
|
103419#0075
|
Document 3
|
|
35
|
Submission #20 Yvonne Steers
|
103419#0076
|
Document 3
|
|
36
|
Submission #21 Debbie Trolove
|
103419#0077
|
Document 3
|
|
37
|
Submission #22 Kathryn Ingram
|
103419#0078
|
Document 3
|
|
38
|
Submission #23 Helen and Peter Liddle
|
103419#0079
|
Document 3
|
|
39
|
Submission #24 Daniel Williams
|
103419#0080
|
Document 3
|
|
40
|
Submission #25 Jamie Flynn
|
103419#0081
|
Document 3
|
|
41
|
Submission #26 Jono Strong
|
103419#0082
|
Document 3
|
|
42
|
Submission #27 Jason Taylor
|
103419#0083
|
Document 3
|
|
43
|
Submission #28 Brett Flynn
|
103419#0084
|
Document 3
|
|
44
|
Submission #29 Charlie Bogard
|
103419#0085
|
Document 3
|
|
45
|
Submission #30 Michelle Bryant
|
103419#0086
|
Document 3
|
|
46
|
Submission #31 Annabelle Linnell
|
103419#0087
|
Document 3
|
|
47
|
Submission #32 Erin Maloney
|
103419#0088
|
Document 3
|
|
48
|
Submission #33 Carol Edwards
|
103419#0027
|
Document 3
|
|
49
|
Submission #34 Bronwyn and Nigel Homburg
|
103419#0029
|
Document 3
|
|
50
|
Submission #35 Belinda Smith
|
103419#0090
|
Document 3
|
|
51
|
Submission #36 Helen Andrews
|
103419#0091
|
Document 3
|
|
52
|
Submission #37 Toni Williams
|
103419#0092
|
Document 3
|
|
53
|
Submission #38 Melissa Grupp
|
103419#0093
|
Document 3
|
|
54
|
Submission #39 Kara Paterson
|
103419#0094
|
Document 3
|
|
55
|
Submission #40 Natasha Dubauskas-Reed
|
103419#0095
|
Document 3
|
|
56
|
Submission #41 Jonathon Stockley
|
103419#0096
|
Document 3
|
|
57
|
Submission #42 Toni Palithorpe
|
103419#0097
|
Document 3
|
|
58
|
Submission #43 Godfrey Quemeneur
|
103419#0098
|
Document 3
|
|
59
|
Submission #44 Keryn Whitney
|
103419#0099
|
Document 3
|
|
60
|
Submission #45 Mehdi Sanssar
|
103419#0100
|
Document 3
|
|
61
|
Submission #46 Murray Linnell
|
103419#0101
|
Document 3
|
|
62
|
Submission #47 Megan Linnell
|
103419#0102
|
Document 3
|
|
63
|
Submission #48 Wayne & Carol Condon
|
103419#0031
|
Document 3
|
|
64
|
Submission #49 Martyn & Jo Taylor
|
103419#0032
|
Document 3
|
|
65
|
Submission #50 Peter & Helen Liddle
|
103419#0033
|
Document 3
|
|
66
|
Submission #51 Jenny & Michael Foote
|
103419#0034
|
Document 3
|
|
67
|
Submission #52 Doug Grieves
|
103419#0035
|
Document 3
|
|
68
|
Submission #53 Jamie Molloy
|
103419#0036
|
Document 3
|
|
69
|
Submission #54 Megan & Murray Linnell
|
103419#0037
|
Document 3
|
|
70
|
Submission #55 John Moroney & Kristyn Bone
|
103419#0038
|
Document 3
|
|
71
|
Submission #56 Dr Phillip Moore
|
103419#0039
|
Document 3
|
|
72
|
Submission #57 Roger & Carol Edwards
|
103419#0043
|
Document 3
|
|
73
|
Submission #58 Michael Bryant & Jonny Brough
|
103419#0044
|
Document 3
|
|
74
|
Submission #59 Ngaire & David Bryant
|
103419#0045
|
Document 3
|
|
75
|
Submission #60 Bronwyn & Nigel Homburg
|
103419#0046
|
Document 3
|
|
76
|
Submission #61 Hawke's Bay Hunt Inc
|
103419#0047
|
Document 3
|
|
77
|
Submission #62 Maraekakaho Residents Group
|
103419#0048
|
Document 3
|
|
78
|
Submission #63 Donald Christopher Bauckham
|
103419#0042
|
Document 3
|
|
79
|
Submission #64 John MacAulay
|
103419#0041
|
Document 3
|
|
80
|
Submission #65 Roger Bruce Edwards
|
103419#0040
|
Document 3
|
Hastings District
Council
